Friday, July 29, 2016

Is there any group of seven fighters that could defeat Aerys II's Kingsguard?

Got this Q through reditt


Is there any group of seven fighters that could defeat Aerys II's Kingsguard? In case you forget, here's who was in it.
1) Gerold Hightower, the White Bull (A good fighter, and strong)
2) Arthur Dayne, Sword of the Morning (Said to be one of the best fighters of all time)
3) Jonothor Darry (Don't know too much about him but he's talented)
4) Prince Lewyn Martell (Don't know too much about him, but he was skilled and got some good action at the Trident)
5) Barristan the Bold (one of the best swordsmen alive)
6) Oswell Whent (skilled enough to be at the ToJ)
7) Jaime Lannister, the Kingslayer (One of the greatest fighters of his age, before hand cut)
Even members like Jonothor Darry that may be less skilled I think that fighters like Arthur Dayne, Barristan and Jaime are enough to carry the rest. So I challenge you to this; Seven fighters who are able to defeat Aerys' Kingsguard.



I like this answer particularly:

  1. Ser Aemon the Dragonknight, to match Ser Arthur Dayne: legends fighting with magic swords!
  2. Ser Criston Cole the Kingmaker, to match Ser Oswell "Westeros Batman" Whent. As I recall, Cole had beaten another who hailed from Harrenhal, hence this one.
  3. Ser Gwayne Corbray, to match Ser Barristan Selmy. A Valyrian Steel sword plus skill to fight evenly with the King Who Bore the Sword, against Barristan the Bold.
  4. Ser Duncan the Tall, to match Ser Gerold Hightower. It's the strength of the White Bull vs Dunk of Flea Bottom.
  5. Ser Loras Tyrell, to match Jaime Lannister. A mirror match!
  6. Ser Balon Swann, to match Prince Lewyn Martell. Marcher lord versus Dornishman.
  7. Ser Ryam Redwyne, to match Ser Jonothor Darry. One of the legends of the past, against a notable, but not exceptional knight.


#1 Agree
#2 No idea
#3 Good Match
#4 Perfect Match
#5 Match 100% that u cant even predict the result
#6 Nope. Ser Balon is only so so good
#7 Ser Redwyne is better




Coming to my selection:

1. Lord Jon Snow against Ser Arthur Dayne - Stargaryan with Valyrian steel Sword has an edge
2.The Hound Vs Ser Oswell Whent
3. Robert Baratheon (link) Vs Ser  Barristan Selmy --- Brute Force wins.. Bobby B unstoppable
4. The Mountain Vs  Ser Gerold Hightower
5. Ser Bronn of Blackwater Vs Jaime Lannister .Bronn plays dirty and wins.
6. Prince Oberyn Martell Vs Prince Lewyn Martell ..The Red Viper has the poisons in his favor.
7. Lady Brienne Vs Ser Jonothor Darry..Brienne's Persistence will pay-off.

Bottomline:
 It may be 7 Vs 1 Arthur Dayne in the end.
The Current 7 will have a decisive win

Update: Damn, I would have added Victarion with his fuming hand but his strength is sea.
Garlan Tyrell can be susbstituted for Bronn, if it is chivalrous fight not no holds barred.

No comments:

Post a Comment